How to Choose A Processor



There are lots of processors to choose from, and these processors come from three different manufacturers. Now of course there are lots manufacturers making CPU's but only about 3 that make CPU's that are Windows 98/95 or NT compatible and are also compatible with most of the software on the market. So we will concentrate on these three manufacturers.
The three manufacturers are:

AMD or Advanced Micro Devices

Cyrix

Intel
 

The limiting factor when ever buying processors is money, in fact that is really the main factor when buying any piece of technology. So realizing everyone has a different budget and different needs in a processor we will try to describe the reasons for getting any particular processor.

CYRIX

Lets start with Cyrix, I have owned Cyrix processors in the past and I can't say that I am really impressed with their performance. They have kind of have dropped out of competition in the processor market they seem to be concentrating on bottom-of-the-market computers. At one time they could actually be considered an alternative, but at this point I don't think anyone should take them seriously, hopefully that will change now that they have been bought by VIA.

AMD

I happen to be a huge AMD fan, but until recently they always had slower chips than the leader of the market, Intel. AMD's new chips the Athlons or K7s are much faster than even the fastest Intel Pentium III available. In the past the great advantage to buying AMD was great performance but at a significantly lower price than Intel. This has all changed now, but it still benefits everyone, because the prices of Pentium III chips have dropped dramatically now that AMD has released their K7s.

There are 3 types of AMD chips currently on the market that are worth taking a look at.
These three are:

K6-2

K6-III

Athlon or K7

The clock speeds of these chips range anywhere from 366Mhz to 650Mhz. Each of these types have support for Intel's MMX instructions set (which is a extension for multimedia instructions within the chip). The chips also have AMD's 3DNOW! (TM) technology, which when supported by software increases performance significantly. The K6-2s are very inexpensive for the power that you get. You can build quite a fast computer with a K6-2 and it wouldn't cost much at all. The K6-IIIs are the next step up for someone who has a little bit more money, but the performance is about the same level as most Intel Celeron chips and for about the same price. The Athlon however is  a different story. Currently these chips are the fastest on the market and slightly more expensive than the newly released Pentium IIIs. 

INTEL

Intel has long been the leader in the CPU market and is also the setter of the standards. Intel chips until recently have always been faster than everything else on the market, this is especially true for floating point operations (mathematical operations with decimal numbers). As I have mentioned this has changed, but Intel chips are still the most compatible chips on the market. Why is this you might ask? Well its because everything is written first to work on Intel chips, and then if it can be fixed a little to work on other brands of processors than all the better.

There are three types of Intel chips on the market to take a close look at. 
These three types are:

Celerons

Pentium IIs

Pentium IIIs

Celerons are Intel's answer to low cost computers. Intel was facing so much competition from AMD's low cost chips that they had to invent a slower chip to compete at a lower price. The newer Celerons are very good chips and tend to run quite fast. Pentium IIs are fast chips as well and are faster than even some K6-III chips, especially in floating point operations. Pentium IIIs were until very recently the fastest chips on the market and the most expensive as well. But now Pentium IIIs have dropped in price and are a great choice for a processor. Pentium IIIs now have Intel's SSE which is another instruction set added to the Intel processors to allow them to run very fast in graphical applications. As with MMX and 3DNOW! the software needs to be written for SSE to take advantage of the instruction set and the increased speed it provides.
 
 

RESEARCH

This is where lots of research begins to enter in the equation if you want to get the fastest processor for your particular use at the lowest price.
The best thing to do is look at 3rd parties that are doing comparisons on chip performances. The best places to do this is at:

anandtech.com

tomshardware.com

These sites do comparisons continuously on processors speeds. In general they will tell you that the fastest Celeron processors are faster than some Pentium IIIs and IIs. Also they will tell you that Intel chips tend to be faster for games than AMD chips, until the Athlon. All numbers on the Athlon say that these chips are faster than anything else for business applications, graphics applications, or gaming applications. AMD K6-IIIs in general score quite well for business applications but suffered under gaming application tests. AMD K6-IIIs are quite fast though and usually do better than most Celerons and Pentium IIs and even some Pentium IIIs in some tests.

SUMMARY:

There are two main chip manufactures that most people should consider when building or buying a PC, AMD and Intel. AMD currently has the fastest chips on the market but who knows how long that will last. Intel's chips are the most compatible with software and should have fewer problems with compatibility with other hardware.
 

RECOMMENDATION:

Currently the best chip on the market is the Athlon 650Mhz, this chip just screams and if you have the seven or eight hundred bucks to shell out I say get it. But more realistically you will want to look at getting an AMD K6-3 or Pentium III for the best balance between speed and price. The newer Pentium IIIs are just about as much money as an Athlon, but not nearly as fast. The Pentium III 450Mhz is only about 50$ more than the AMD K6-III 450Mhz but the Pentium III would run much faster for games and graphics applications, the only reason to get the AMD K6-III is if you only do business applications and you want save the 50$. The final recommendation would be for someone who really wants to save money. These people should probably get a Celeron chip if they are playing games or an AMD K6-2 if they are doing business applications. Prices right now between the chips are quite similar.
 

NOTE:

Overclocking is done all the time on lots of different processors, if you don't know what overclocking is, don't worry about it because you don't really need it. For those of you who are interested in overclocking your CPU you will want to stay away from the Athlon and Pentium IIIs and Pentium IIs. The Celerons, AMD K6-2s and K6-IIIs however can be overclock quite easily. The Celeron 300A is easy to overclock and can reach speeds of over 500Mhz, other Celerons like the 400 can easily be overclocked to 550Mhz. For information about overclocking see the links above for anandtech.com or tomshardware.com.
 


Copyright © 1999 Avalanche Creations. All rights reserved.
Revised: October 12, 1999 .